• mindbleach@sh.itjust.works
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    arrow-down
    2
    ·
    18 days ago

    Are you kvetching because the most direct possible answer was only the second thing I said? Not counting where I personally explained it to you personally an entire year ago.

    After the more recent clarification, you made clear you still thought monopoly meant illegal. “Everyone calling Steam a monopoly is implying that.” My response was “The point of acknowledging Steam’s monopoly is recognizing things could go bad.”

    Now Steam is no longer a Monopoly in the legal sense, are you no longer concerned about the amount of power Steam has?

    I’d be massively less concerned. A game off Steam, but on all those competitors, would still be seen by the majority of customers. Those competitors have motivation toward pro-consumer intercompatibility. Customers have a choice based on whatever they consider important - like user interface. Publishers would care about percentages, because the choice is not between giving Valve their pound of flesh, or an anticipated sequel taking two years to break even.

    Basically it turns out competition is kind of important for capitalism? The cases where a monopoly works out better are rare… and fragile.

    • CileTheSane@lemmy.ca
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      18 days ago

      It was the sixth thing you said, well after you invited me to a conversation you hadn’t even started yet. You seem upset that people aren’t reading your mind to know what definitions you are wanting to use, or to know the thing you are concerned about is the thing you haven’t even said yet. If you want to have conversations with people you need to communicate what’s in your head to them first, instead of getting pissy that they aren’t responding to the things you haven’t said.

      I never said Steam being a Monopoly is a good thing, but Steam being a monopoly is not because Steam is a bad thing. I would absolutely love more alternatives to Steam in the market, but that needs to come from competitors who aren’t garbage. Calling Steam a monopoly is again irrelevant because what do you propose be done about it? Break up Steam into smaller companies? Steam is a monopoly because it does better than the competition, that’s not legal grounds to break it up. Encourage competition? That can be done regardless of Steam being a monopoly. But competition needs to bring more to the table than “not being Steam” in order to be supported.

      • mindbleach@sh.itjust.works
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        arrow-down
        2
        ·
        17 days ago

        If “what do you think the word means” was my first comment… that makes the next comment the second.

        Calling Steam a monopoly is again irrelevant because what do you propose be done about it?

        … you still don’t get it. Even now, you’re insisting the label demands action. How many times-- literally, I’m asking. How many times do we have to tell you, that’s not how it works?

        Nobody but y’all are talking about breaking up Valve, because that’s what you jump to from the word monopoly. Like the risk of anticompetitive abuse is inseparable from committing that abuse and must therefore be punished. You quoted my link to Cornell explaining that’s wrong. Why did it have no lasting impact on your brain?

        I just told you, there are times where a monopoly works out better. I told you a year ago and yesterday. I have a root comment in this thread which begins, first thing, “Their monopoly is preferable to many alternatives, but.” What comes after the “but” is not ‘we must destroy this intolerable stranglehold.’ That comment does conclude: “the precondition for abusing a monopoly is being a monopoly.” It is a risk. It is a fact to be concerned about, not necessarily an immediate call to action.

        The risk is still real when what we do about it is shrug and wait.

        • CileTheSane@lemmy.ca
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          2
          arrow-down
          1
          ·
          17 days ago

          The risk is still real when what we do about it is shrug and wait.

          I’m going to quote the thing I said before, that you quoted and didn’t actually reply to:

          what do you propose be done about it?

          You’re going on and on about how important it is the we recognize Steam is legally speaking a monopoly, but for the life of me I don’t know what your point is. “Steam has a large market share”? No shit. Maybe I’m getting confused because you keep insisting the sky is azure, not blue, and I’m expecting you to have a fucking point where the difference matters.

          I don’t see any practical difference between “we need to be aware that they could potentially abuse their position” and “shrug and wait.”

          • mindbleach@sh.itjust.works
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            1
            arrow-down
            2
            ·
            edit-2
            17 days ago

            If you repeat the question again, the answer will still be, that’s not how it works. Me explaining that mistake is the reply. I am only “going on and on” because you continue demanding this explanation, and then, you ignore it.

            The sentence you quoted contains the words “what we do about it” followed by what we do about it, and what we do about it is, not much. It is not the sort of problem you necessarily do something about. The reason for saying so anyway is cleverly hidden at the start of the quoted sentence.

            It is still a problem. It is still something we have to stay aware of, to prevent complacency… or whatever else you’d call it when simply saying “Steam is a monopoly” unleashes a torrent of denials and accusations, as if the fact must be followed by a call to action obliterating everybody’s favorite DRM vendor.

            Steam has overwhelming market share, and could abuse that in a heartbeat, in a way that no merely competitive company can. Steam is so large that not being on it, for whatever reason, can be a death knell for sales. They wield such power that their cautious selectivity dictates which games most customers would even see offered - and an accept-all policy would dilute the shopping experience for nearly everyone.

            All of that is real even if there’s not a safe and satisfying alternative, immediately to-hand. Unless you’ve got a magic wand laying around, there’s nothing I’d ask you to do about this situation, besides maybe could you stop asking me what to do about it? It’s a systemic risk. That doesn’t mean it’s an emergency.

            • CileTheSane@lemmy.ca
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              2
              arrow-down
              1
              ·
              17 days ago

              So your response to Steam being a monopoly is indistinguishable from

              shrug and wait.

              As I said before, you don’t actually have a point other then pedantry. It is very important to you that people use the legal definition of monopoly and apply it to Steam, behaviors don’t have to change at all, actions don’t have to be taken, but my god you will spend days arguing for the label being used.

              • mindbleach@sh.itjust.works
                link
                fedilink
                English
                arrow-up
                1
                arrow-down
                2
                ·
                16 days ago

                It was not a distinction… it was bluntly rephrasing “it’s probably fine” in the vain hope it might finally get through. I am explicitly telling you there’s no mandatory action, and you’re still posturing like that’s a gotcha. You don’t get it. You never have. I’m not even mad, it’s just ridiculous. What sequence of words would help at this point?

                Yes, acknowledging Steam’s blatant monopoly over the PC gaming market is important, especially when the dryest mention of that fact has people digging their heels in to argue ‘nuh uh.’ People endlessly parroting ‘so what?’ are not meaningfully different. You are still implicitly arguing against that label, as if that label demands decisive change.

                It is crucial for people to recognize - this is what monopoly looks like. It’s never the cartoon absolute, and it’s usually really fucking bad. Steam is a vanishingly rare example of a monopoly that works out fine. It is still a monopoly. The “fine” part is far less durable than the “monopoly” part.

                I’ve tried several times to exit this conversation when it sounded like you understood that. I already explained this a year ago and kinda figured, okay, that guy’s been told, box checked. I am literally telling you the practical path forward is whatever you were doing already, just so long as you don’t deny the obvious. Why did you make this take so long? I possess enough patience and concern, such that if you ask the same confused questions yet again, be it today or next year, I will still try to help you figure out what I have been saying in plain English the entire time. If you consider that a character flaw then maybe we should discuss mistake as well.

                • CileTheSane@lemmy.ca
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  arrow-up
                  2
                  arrow-down
                  1
                  ·
                  16 days ago

                  I am explicitly telling you there’s no mandatory action

                  But you said before

                  The risk is still real when what we do about it is shrug and wait.

                  And now your saying to do nothing but shrug and wait.

                  you are still implicitly arguing against that label

                  Implicit arguments are allowed now? People insisting that Steam is a monopoly are implicitly arguing action should be taken about it.

                  In the same vein as your claim that insisting people use the word monopoly, is just insisting on the word used and nothing more; me arguing that the word used doesn’t matter, is just me saying it doesn’t matter what word you use if the actions are the same and nothing more.

                  It is crucial for people to recognize…

                  And then do nothing about it? Why is that so crucial?

                  Steam is a vanishingly rare example of a monopoly that works out fine. It is still a monopoly. The “fine” part is far less durable than the “monopoly” part.

                  I don’t disagree with you, I just don’t see the point you’re making other than pedantry. “Steam is fine right now, it might not always be fine, I suggest doing nothing about it” has no practical difference from “Steam is fine. Do nothing about it.” The actionables are the same.

                  I am literally telling you the practical path forward is whatever you were doing already

                  “I only care about the language being used.” As I said, pedantry and nothing else.

                  be it today or next year, I will still try

                  And will you be just as upset in a year from now when your failure to say anything of substance has again caused me to not remember you?

                  Let’s take a step back here: You want people to acknowledge that Steam meets the legal definition of a Monopoly. I acknowledged that. We both agree that by the same legal definition Steam is a legal monopoly. We agree that Steam is currently fine but that doesn’t mean it always will be. We also agree that beyond these acknowledgements you aren’t suggesting any action be taken, or behaviours be changed.

                  So now we’re just arguing about the words used to describe your argument, just like you were arguing about the words used to define Steam: further pedantry. We’re not going to find any common ground between you thinking your distinction is meaningful and me calling it meaningless.

                  • mindbleach@sh.itjust.works
                    link
                    fedilink
                    English
                    arrow-up
                    1
                    arrow-down
                    1
                    ·
                    16 days ago

                    And now your saying to do nothing but shrug and wait.

                    That’s what I’ve said the entire time. That sentence does not mean “the risk becomes real only if we are fools who do nothing.” It means “the risk is real even when the appropriate course of action is to do nothing.” It is not a distinction.

                    People insisting that Steam is a monopoly are implicitly arguing action should be taken about it.

                    No.

                    it doesn’t matter what word you use

                    It does because basically any other example would be a problem that needs solving. Even now, it has far-reaching effects, some of them dire, and we tolerate them because any direct solution would be worse. Those problems are still real. The label is still accurate and necessary.

                    Stop saying it’s not a monopoly just because we tolerate it.

                    I don’t disagree with you

                    Demonstrably false. If you think saying it’s a monopoly requires action, that is the central disagreement.

                    And will you be just as upset in a year from now when your failure to say anything of substance has again caused me to not remember you?

                    If you’re still telling people an obvious monopoly is not a monopoly if the monopoly is kind of okay, yes, I will still explain why that’s the exact same mistake. Internalize the definitions you claim to acknowledge. Stop saying it’s not a monopoly just because we tolerate it. You cannot agree that it meets the definition and still argue about the words used. That’s denying it meets the definition.