People keep asking me, and I haven’t really had an answer, but now yeah, I’m thinking I’m back.

  • 0 Posts
  • 8 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: March 18th, 2025

help-circle
  • There’s a lot to unpack here, and the TLDR is that his comment is one huge doompost, and your comment is one large concern troll. I’m engaging with it anyway, not because you’ll read this, but someone else may.

    First, the guy above us has basically suffered a depressive episode. “Might as well give the kids an A” and “the ship has sailed” and “no one will write software anymore.” These are defeatist attitudes. Maybe the guy just needs a place to vent his frustrations and doesn’t have anyone close to him. But in my opinion, sharing these thoughts out loud sets a bad example both as a senior engineer and as a role model for children and students of any kind. It’s giving up, it’s quitting, and it’s demoralizing. I believe he should have kept that to himself, unless this was a cry for help, in which case this is all the help I can provide and the only way I know how.

    Second, the person I’m replying to leveled a lot of logical fallacies, real “Flood The Zone With Shit” shit. We got to start with the Appeal To Authority. Tenure is not the mark of an effective leader, but it’s all they can offer. 25 and 30 year engineers also puts them at about 55 to 65 years old, nearing retirement. They are not invested in the future of the industry, they are on the cusp of leaving it behind. So even if they were who they say they were, why should I believe them?

    We also have a lot of Strawmen. “Downvoters have never used an AI before,” has the same energy as “Cryptocurrency haters have never minted an NFT before,” implying that AI resistance is founded on ignorance. “He’s just telling the truth,” is also really sneaky, because it primes us to take it at face value as fact. But it’s just like, an opinion maaan. “We’d be throwing away a massive productivity boost” is just straight up propaganda, may as well have just copy pasted Sam Altman for that one.

    So now here’s from my experience. If you’re willing to take my word for it, I’m a 10-year engineer who’s been using Opus and Fable at work. Here’s how AI changed our company:

    • Productivity is not up, we are still beholden to clients who demand time to preview the releases. Management has forced us to cram more features into a given release, causing the clients to delay so they can reevaluate it. End result, we ship fewer features in a given month, not more.
    • Despite all this extra work being done, we still are working 40 plus hours a week.
    • Team morale is way down, as everyone believes that the only reason we’re using it this much is because management wants to lay people off.
    • Engineers are starting to snap at each other for trying to ask questions about new features, and the new favorite catch phrase of all is “I don’t know, have you asked Claude?”
    • 32,000 line merge requests are now the norm. The bulk of that is unit tests that failed to account for basic UX: is it “nice” to use the software? These code reviews will inevitably let some large vulnerability through, so most code reviewers are taking longer to review so that they don’t get the blame.
    • Engineers are getting lazier writing their skill files and prompts, leading to increased churn. They’re using AI to write the skills that AI will ingest, leading to generational decay.
    • I now have to scrutinize the output of engineers that I used to value and respect, and after multiple iterations of code reviews with them, they begin to take it personally. This destroys our team cohesion and camaraderie.
    • Engineers are burning through their token allotments so fast that they are now twiddling their thumbs for an entire sprint until it can replenish. Management cannot decide if this is a good thing or a bad thing and are now so confused that they are hitting people with the carrot.

    So… I said it before and I’ll say it again. THIS is the trillion dollar technology? It makes a bunch of people more tired, more angry, more scared, and more alone.


  • There’s nothing generally wrong with water cooling depending on your skill and commitment to the building process. There’s 2 ways to go with water cooling: an AIO (all in one) cooler, like this, or a custom loop, like this. The AIO you just follow the instruction manual and you’re set, a custom loop you have to buy all the parts, all the tubing, all the fittings, and assemble it all yourself. You have to really know what you’re doing.

    My personal preference, however, is also to stick with air cooling. When an AIO breaks, the entire unit has to be replaced. When a tower air cooler breaks, its just the fan, which you can swap out more cheaply and easily.

    OP if you live near a Microcenter, go check them out! They don’t do delivery orders, but they are a goldmine of hardware and enthusiast knowledge, and their prices are usually pretty reasonable********.



  • Well we’re already in agreement that programming is merely one medium, but with AI being used as a replacement for just about any form of human expression - audiovisual arts, writing, mathematics, information sciences, etc - all mediums are under the same looming threat. So if we’re giving up on one medium, we’re gonna be giving up on most of them. And without them, we can’t really pass on those lessons. Learning doesn’t exist in the abstract, we also have to put those lessons into practice. If OP wasn’t a programmer but a musician, let’s say, then I’d have the same admittedly harsh reaction. I don’t see any reason to doompost about the end of programming, or the end of music, or the end of learning.

    Finally, I don’t really know where you’re going with the printing press analogy? Like, yes? I want children to take pride in themselves for any skill they practice and enjoy? But the printing press isn’t really analogous to AI, for a number of reasons:

    • LLM’s, by their nature, produce an output that is of the same type as its inputs: text begets text, images beget images, etc. As such, you can make LLM’s generate their own instructions and feed that back into it. As we know from the Claude Code leaks, Anthropic was doing just that, using CC to ask C to work on CC.

    • Printing presses did not create more… printing presses. They created more print. Not even more words, the press itself didn’t conjure Martin Luther’s 95 theses into existence, it just copied an existing text. Which makes it a useful addition to our ability to create, not an outright replacement.

    • Printing presses were still human operated machines, requiring knowledge of its inner workings to maintain, repair, and operate. They’re not agentic, self-sustaining systems. Though you could argue that even AI is not self-sustaining, once its power grid fails. By the by, the printing press didn’t threaten global ecological catastrophe all on its own.

    • Printing presses did not, in fact, extinguish the pencil. Schools do still teach kids how to write. Heck, humble brag time, even I get compliments on my penmanship from time to time, and I write in all capital letters!


  • Why would I want my kids to code at this point?

    Because you want your children to learn the value and joy of creative expression? To learn the ability to solve problems – of any discipline, not just software – for themselves? To give them the ability to think critically and protect themselves in an increasingly hostile world? To feel the satisfaction and confidence boost of overcoming a difficult challenge?

    I don’t know you, I don’t even know if you have kids or if this is just a rhetorical argument. But still, you don’t value any of your 30 years of experience enough to pass that knowledge on to a new generation? Because that’s what you’re telling us, and it doesn’t have anything to do with AI. That’s what we in the business call a You problem. You can feel defeated, that’s normal and I sympathize with it, but you can leave your capitulation at the door. Those kids deserve better.



  • The incessant oversupply of vibe-coded decomps/recomps/ports comes from the same sense of entitlement as people going around emulator communities asking for free games.

    Those people finally found someone who wouldn’t say “no,” and that someone was Claude. They’re the “give me something” or “make me something” crowd, and they never had high standards or shame in the first place.