• 0 Posts
  • 6 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 15th, 2023

help-circle
  • Totally agree with you a call by AP would be much more certain than this no-name publication. A call by nearly anything else would be more credible.

    I was just irked at the suggestion this shouldn’t have been posted, it had relevant useful information and I’m glad I was exposed to it. Sure this is likely an attempt at a clickbait headline by some small website, but it’s very simple to just store this away as that and still get some value.

    I also have an irritation with the association between decision desks calling an election and them actually being certified. People mix this up most of the time.in.my experience and don’t realize that a news agency calling something has literally 0 legal connection to the race being won.

    And for your final point about the 100% accuracy except when incorrect totals are counted kind of enhances point. Counties often do not report things correctly as fast as we want them to, but they have no obligation to.


  • The thing you are missing is the accuracy of decision desks has absolutely nothing to do with the argument of calling elections. Even if they were 100% accurate (they aren’t, I just found 5 from past 10 years with a cursory Google search) the point still stands.

    An election being “called” means nothing more than a journalistic institution deciding that they think the outcome is certain enough to publish. That’s it!

    That was my whole point from the start till now. Your pedantic obsession with the accuracy of decision desks has nothing to do with my claims. But go ahead and keep beating that straw man if it makes you feel better. I’ll happily prove they get it wrong despite that being an entirely different argument.


  • Are you really suggesting that the only time an “actually credible decision desk” has made a bad call was over 25 years ago? I used that example because it was huge and top of mind, I’m sure if I did some research I could find plenty of retractions between then and now.

    And how is it that I have suggested Florida and Congress are on par with AlterNet? I clearly stated that this was a weak source, I’ve never disagreed with you on that front.

    It was your claiming that this election hasn’t been “called” I took issue with. Your original post suggested there was some official “calling” mechanism we are waiting for and there isn’t. I can’t help but notice you were pretty silent about that despite it being the crux of my disagreement.

    This outlet is saying their analysis suggests that Boebert has such a slim chance at victory they are calling it. That is newsworthy, it’s up to the reader to evaluate the source.

    I’m glad this was posted and I found it informative.



  • While I won’t argue that US election campaigns are long, the counting afterwards has a good explanation. The two big factors that make counting votes so complex is we have 50 versions of elections, and we bote for everything at once.

    I’ve heard that French presidential campaigns take like one night but if I recall correctly the only thing being voted on is the presidential candidate. This makes hand sifting of the ballot into piles extremely easy and then a machine or person can just count them.

    In the US you vote for a whole slew of things all at once. Proposed changes to state law through propositions, your house representative, your governor, you STATE representative, senator, STATE senator, sheriff, university head, city council, and on and on and on. So tabulating all these is a bit more complicated.

    Then you have the 50 different systems. So Mississippi is going to take a while, that’s because they allow for absentee mail in ballots to come in 5 days late and if a voter on election day didn’t have proper ID they have 5 days to shoe proper ID and then vote. This guarantees it is going to take long after voting day to get results.


  • Big money donors did not swing from Democrats to Republicans, this is a flawed analysis. The uptick in republican top 40 funding came from existing republican funders greatly increasing their funding levels and a large part elon musk dumping half a billion into Republican hands.

    None of that is Democrat funders switching sides as you are suggesting. And it is not even clear to me if democrat funders gave less this go around adjusting for inflation. It seems Soros didn’t give money to the DNC but he instead funded democratic organizations in different ways.

    Votes being prioritized more than dollars makes no sense whatsoever considering dollars are a major way to secure votes.