We recently became exclusive after going on several dates for a month. We enjoy each other’s company and conversations, and agreed the time flies by every time, but he got weird and wishy-washy about Thanksgiving.
He even brought up the topic during our date but wasn’t asking to spend time together that day. He kept saying he doesn’t like traditional Thanksgiving food, so I later casually mentioned there are places that do both Thanksgiving dinner and regular food, but it was as if I was asking him to meet my family or something. He finally agreed after wavering, to which I later said I don’t want him to feel pressured and it’s okay if he wants to keep that day open, and then he said he would like to see me but doesn’t like the traditional dinner so we can play it by ear. It feels strange how something like a non-romantic holiday can be affecting his mindset so much, so this has been on my mind even though we’ve talked about it. Also he himself shared that his family isn’t in the area so he’d be spending it alone and doesn’t have plans.
Please be kind with me. Any advice or wisdom would be really appreciated! Would you feel comfortable meeting 1:1 on the day of the holiday under these circumstances? Does it make sense that he is so visibly nervous about it? I don’t really understand to be honest. It’s not like it’s Valentine’s Day and I’m asking him to travel somewhere or do something over the top. I really want this to work out and do find the constructive, supportive comments to be helpful on this platform.
Maybe talk to him and Lemmy? Or at least give the people asking questions more info. Are you both like 20 or something?
Regardless of age, maybe you have to ask yourself some questions about you before being in a relationship.
Based on your post history, it seems like you communicate more with asklemmy than you do with your boyfriend
I wish he were on Lemmy so we could ask him what has him all frightened. How old is he, btw? If he’s in his late teens/very early 20s, maybe he’s still kinda “new to life” and he’s never done anything with a partner during the holidays and it just feels… scary, somehow?
My guess is that it’s more the Thanksgiving conversations that’ll happen after. I don’t know the family but I’d be surprised if his folks/relatives etc wouldn’t ask what he did for Thanksgiving, which brings you into the conversation perhaps earlier than he wanted. (Depending on the age, moms can get very stereotypical when hearing about a new partner etc.)
As far as holidays go, a Thanksgiving date is the single most intimate holiday date I could imagine. New Year’s date, Valentine’s date — these are easy peasy. We’re dressed up, we’re going out, we’re looking cute, it’s fun. Thanksgiving is me and my weird family staying inside and and watching sports and wearing frumpy sweatpants so we don’t bust a button when we sneak in to the kitchen late to sneak a 6th piece of pie. If I’d only been dating someone a month, I’m not sure I’d be ready for a Thanksgiving date for next year’s Thanksgiving yet. It’s like my partner pooping while I’m in the shower — it’s a very different kind of intimacy, and one that you generally don’t have until much later in the relationship.
OP said that his family isn’t in the area though, so that kind of misses the point, doesn’t it?
Nah, the tenor of the holiday is the same regardless of how far from your family you are located. If I invite you on a date for Valentine’s Day, there’s nothing you can do or say to remove the implications from the date; Thanksgiving is the same. When you invite me to a Thanksgiving date, you’re saying we’re family now, and that is a lot.
Ah I see. I’m from Europe and we don’t have Thanksgiving over here so I’m not familiar with the connotations. Thanks for clarifying!
No worries! Thanksgiving is my favorite holiday, and so I love talking about it. Getting together for a day with your family and eating every delicious food you can imagine and not leaving the house and watching sports is my ideal day. If you come from a culture that has a traditional harvest festival, I would strongly recommend having some sort of potluck to celebrate with your favorite humans.
I’m not sure Ask is the correct spot for this.
Maybe try https://piefed.social/c/relationships@lemmy.world
I notice the post history of questions on relationships. And previous suggestions was on communication with a new partner. These are valid ideas.
He might have some baggage from childhood about how Thanksgiving and other major holidays are “a very big deal” and he doesn’t know what to do going it alone.
Probably too early in the relationship to dig into his childhood and ask a ton of prying questions. I would probably just casually choose a different day, leave Thanksgiving open, and make a mental note to see if this same thing happens at Christmas and Easter.
Go over to relationship advice
I could be wrong, but I wonder if he has a sore spot that we don’t know of. Maybe something related to his family, or to Thanksgiving as a concept, or to his sense of self, or to the relationship. There are many options.
This is something you could gently talk to him about, if he feels comfortable with that.
You can approach the conversation trying to start with a mutual purpose: what do you want out of the conversation? What do you want for the relationship long term regarding this topic?
You can also approach the conversation by being open about your vulnerability. What vulnerable emotions do you feel when you notice him not responding as you’d like regarding Thanksgiving? Do you feel alone? Unheard? Frustrated? Lost? Confused?
If you can and if he wants to, you can try to understand his own vulnerability. It’s important to do this kindly and compassionately.
I hope this helps. Let me know if you have questions!
I’d feel fine about it but I can imagine how another person might feel like doing anything like a traditional Thanksgiving raises domestication alarms. For Christmas dinner the usual answer is a Chinese restaurant. Maybe that works for Thanksgiving too.




