Multiple people are actively trying to dissuade you from that assumption. That’s the opposite of us implying it.
The point of acknowledging Steam’s monopoly is recognizing things could go bad. One store fucking up would fuck up this entire market. That’s what it means when y’all worry about Gabe having a heart attack.
I welcomed you to the conversation because you could not discuss this until you understood what this is.
That’s what it means when y’all worry about Gabe having a heart attack.
That’s irrelevant to any monopoly status. “I like thing, I hope owner of thing doesn’t have a heart attack so I can continue to use thing.”
Here, let me save you a lot of time in the future:
“Legally speaking Steam qualifies as a monopoly due to its market share. Also legally speaking, being a monopoly because your competitors suck is completely legal.”
That gets people to the point you’re trying to make a hell of a lot faster than whatever this was.
“Legally speaking Steam qualifies as a monopoly due to its market share. Also legally speaking, being a monopoly because your competitors suck is completely legal.”
You’ve previously had paragraphs long posts with someone because they were using the dictionary definition of “monopoly” instead of the legal definition, and then instead of clarifying what definition you are using you let yourself walk into the exact same situation and you accuse other people of not learning?
The dictionary definition of “monopoly” is not wrong, it’s in the fucking dictionary. The legal definition is not wrong either, it all depends what you are talking about. Considering the original post wasn’t about the legality of the situation at all, there’s no reason for someone to assume the legal definition over the dictionary definition.
Then, when someone acknowledges that your definition is also correct you mock them for agreeing with you, then you’re surprised when you have difficulty getting people to agree with you.
So it looks like you have no interest in having a meaningful conversation about the topic, and instead just go on and on about a pedantic point that is a distinction without a difference.
Excuse me for thinking, after I already walked you through this an entire year ago, that you had it straight.
The legal definition is not wrong either, it all depends what you are talking about.
In what universe are you explaining this to me? Considering there’s obviously stores besides Steam, there’s no reason to infer someone must mean the rigid absolute dictionary definition of monopoly - especially after they repeatedly specify that’s not what they fucking mean.
If someone scoffing ‘finally you get it’ makes you stop getting it, then you did not get it.
Meanwhile.
Back at the point:
Steam is a monopoly. They are the one store that matters, on PC, and being excluded can ruin your game. Either you comprehend this, and accept that that’s what the word means when people talk about real markets, or you just plain don’t. If it’s “distinction without a difference” then why did you spend all this fucking time bickering about the distinction? I’m not the one making it. I’m here telling you, yet again, that the cartoon absolute and a simple supermajority are both forms of monopoly.
Having that power is a concern even if it’s not intrinsically an abuse.
Your first comment was “What do you think the word means.” not “What do you think the word means in a legal sense.” Seeing as you’ve had this whole issue a year ago you should have been able to see this coming and clarify what you were talking about. Especially considering a perfectly reasonable answer to the question “What do you think (word) means” is the dictionary definition.
especially after they repeatedly specify that’s not what they fucking mean.
It was not repeatedly specified. As soon as it was actually specified I continued with that definition.
Back at the point: Steam is a monopoly. They are the one store that matters, on PC, and being excluded can ruin your game.
If that’s the point it took you six posts to say anything related to it, so what the fuck were you going on about before that?
If it’s “distinction without a difference” then why did you spend all this fucking time bickering about the distinction?
Your 5 posts before getting to your point was you bickering about the distinction.
And the reason I say it’s a distinction without a difference is because it’s irrelevant to the point you claim to be concerned about (but took 6 posts to actually make). Let’s say Steam had 45% market share and had a dozen competitors with less than 5% market share each. Now Steam is no longer a Monopoly in the legal sense, are you no longer concerned about the amount of power Steam has?
Are you kvetching because the most direct possible answer was only the second thing I said? Not counting where I personally explained it to you personally an entire year ago.
After the more recent clarification, you made clear you still thought monopoly meant illegal. “Everyone calling Steam a monopoly is implying that.” My response was “The point of acknowledging Steam’s monopoly is recognizing things could go bad.”
Now Steam is no longer a Monopoly in the legal sense, are you no longer concerned about the amount of power Steam has?
I’d be massively less concerned. A game off Steam, but on all those competitors, would still be seen by the majority of customers. Those competitors have motivation toward pro-consumer intercompatibility. Customers have a choice based on whatever they consider important - like user interface. Publishers would care about percentages, because the choice is not between giving Valve their pound of flesh, or an anticipated sequel taking two years to break even.
Basically it turns out competition is kind of important for capitalism? The cases where a monopoly works out better are rare… and fragile.
It was the sixth thing you said, well after you invited me to a conversation you hadn’t even started yet. You seem upset that people aren’t reading your mind to know what definitions you are wanting to use, or to know the thing you are concerned about is the thing you haven’t even said yet. If you want to have conversations with people you need to communicate what’s in your head to them first, instead of getting pissy that they aren’t responding to the things you haven’t said.
I never said Steam being a Monopoly is a good thing, but Steam being a monopoly is not because Steam is a bad thing. I would absolutely love more alternatives to Steam in the market, but that needs to come from competitors who aren’t garbage. Calling Steam a monopoly is again irrelevant because what do you propose be done about it? Break up Steam into smaller companies? Steam is a monopoly because it does better than the competition, that’s not legal grounds to break it up. Encourage competition? That can be done regardless of Steam being a monopoly. But competition needs to bring more to the table than “not being Steam” in order to be supported.
If “what do you think the word means” was my first comment… that makes the next comment the second.
Calling Steam a monopoly is again irrelevant because what do you propose be done about it?
… you still don’t get it. Even now, you’re insisting the label demands action. How many times-- literally, I’m asking. How many times do we have to tell you, that’s not how it works?
Nobody but y’all are talking about breaking up Valve, because that’s what you jump to from the word monopoly. Like the risk of anticompetitive abuse is inseparable from committing that abuse and must therefore be punished. You quoted my link to Cornell explaining that’s wrong. Why did it have no lasting impact on your brain?
I just told you, there are times where a monopoly works out better. I told you a year ago and yesterday. I have a root comment in this thread which begins, first thing, “Their monopoly is preferable to many alternatives, but.” What comes after the “but” is not ‘we must destroy this intolerable stranglehold.’ That comment does conclude: “the precondition for abusing a monopoly is being a monopoly.” It is a risk. It is a fact to be concerned about, not necessarily an immediate call to action.
The risk is still real when what we do about it is shrug and wait.
Multiple people are actively trying to dissuade you from that assumption. That’s the opposite of us implying it.
The point of acknowledging Steam’s monopoly is recognizing things could go bad. One store fucking up would fuck up this entire market. That’s what it means when y’all worry about Gabe having a heart attack.
I welcomed you to the conversation because you could not discuss this until you understood what this is.
That’s irrelevant to any monopoly status. “I like thing, I hope owner of thing doesn’t have a heart attack so I can continue to use thing.”
Here, let me save you a lot of time in the future:
“Legally speaking Steam qualifies as a monopoly due to its market share. Also legally speaking, being a monopoly because your competitors suck is completely legal.”
That gets people to the point you’re trying to make a hell of a lot faster than whatever this was.
I have told you as much in the past, and you didn’t listen then either.
Do you understand it - even now? Or are you just saying it?
So let me get this straight:
You’ve previously had paragraphs long posts with someone because they were using the dictionary definition of “monopoly” instead of the legal definition, and then instead of clarifying what definition you are using you let yourself walk into the exact same situation and you accuse other people of not learning?
The dictionary definition of “monopoly” is not wrong, it’s in the fucking dictionary. The legal definition is not wrong either, it all depends what you are talking about. Considering the original post wasn’t about the legality of the situation at all, there’s no reason for someone to assume the legal definition over the dictionary definition.
Then, when someone acknowledges that your definition is also correct you mock them for agreeing with you, then you’re surprised when you have difficulty getting people to agree with you.
So it looks like you have no interest in having a meaningful conversation about the topic, and instead just go on and on about a pedantic point that is a distinction without a difference.
I literally did.
Excuse me for thinking, after I already walked you through this an entire year ago, that you had it straight.
In what universe are you explaining this to me? Considering there’s obviously stores besides Steam, there’s no reason to infer someone must mean the rigid absolute dictionary definition of monopoly - especially after they repeatedly specify that’s not what they fucking mean.
If someone scoffing ‘finally you get it’ makes you stop getting it, then you did not get it.
Meanwhile.
Back at the point:
Steam is a monopoly. They are the one store that matters, on PC, and being excluded can ruin your game. Either you comprehend this, and accept that that’s what the word means when people talk about real markets, or you just plain don’t. If it’s “distinction without a difference” then why did you spend all this fucking time bickering about the distinction? I’m not the one making it. I’m here telling you, yet again, that the cartoon absolute and a simple supermajority are both forms of monopoly.
Having that power is a concern even if it’s not intrinsically an abuse.
Your first comment was “What do you think the word means.” not “What do you think the word means in a legal sense.” Seeing as you’ve had this whole issue a year ago you should have been able to see this coming and clarify what you were talking about. Especially considering a perfectly reasonable answer to the question “What do you think (word) means” is the dictionary definition.
It was not repeatedly specified. As soon as it was actually specified I continued with that definition.
If that’s the point it took you six posts to say anything related to it, so what the fuck were you going on about before that?
Your 5 posts before getting to your point was you bickering about the distinction.
And the reason I say it’s a distinction without a difference is because it’s irrelevant to the point you claim to be concerned about (but took 6 posts to actually make). Let’s say Steam had 45% market share and had a dozen competitors with less than 5% market share each. Now Steam is no longer a Monopoly in the legal sense, are you no longer concerned about the amount of power Steam has?
Are you kvetching because the most direct possible answer was only the second thing I said? Not counting where I personally explained it to you personally an entire year ago.
After the more recent clarification, you made clear you still thought monopoly meant illegal. “Everyone calling Steam a monopoly is implying that.” My response was “The point of acknowledging Steam’s monopoly is recognizing things could go bad.”
I’d be massively less concerned. A game off Steam, but on all those competitors, would still be seen by the majority of customers. Those competitors have motivation toward pro-consumer intercompatibility. Customers have a choice based on whatever they consider important - like user interface. Publishers would care about percentages, because the choice is not between giving Valve their pound of flesh, or an anticipated sequel taking two years to break even.
Basically it turns out competition is kind of important for capitalism? The cases where a monopoly works out better are rare… and fragile.
It was the sixth thing you said, well after you invited me to a conversation you hadn’t even started yet. You seem upset that people aren’t reading your mind to know what definitions you are wanting to use, or to know the thing you are concerned about is the thing you haven’t even said yet. If you want to have conversations with people you need to communicate what’s in your head to them first, instead of getting pissy that they aren’t responding to the things you haven’t said.
I never said Steam being a Monopoly is a good thing, but Steam being a monopoly is not because Steam is a bad thing. I would absolutely love more alternatives to Steam in the market, but that needs to come from competitors who aren’t garbage. Calling Steam a monopoly is again irrelevant because what do you propose be done about it? Break up Steam into smaller companies? Steam is a monopoly because it does better than the competition, that’s not legal grounds to break it up. Encourage competition? That can be done regardless of Steam being a monopoly. But competition needs to bring more to the table than “not being Steam” in order to be supported.
If “what do you think the word means” was my first comment… that makes the next comment the second.
… you still don’t get it. Even now, you’re insisting the label demands action. How many times-- literally, I’m asking. How many times do we have to tell you, that’s not how it works?
Nobody but y’all are talking about breaking up Valve, because that’s what you jump to from the word monopoly. Like the risk of anticompetitive abuse is inseparable from committing that abuse and must therefore be punished. You quoted my link to Cornell explaining that’s wrong. Why did it have no lasting impact on your brain?
I just told you, there are times where a monopoly works out better. I told you a year ago and yesterday. I have a root comment in this thread which begins, first thing, “Their monopoly is preferable to many alternatives, but.” What comes after the “but” is not ‘we must destroy this intolerable stranglehold.’ That comment does conclude: “the precondition for abusing a monopoly is being a monopoly.” It is a risk. It is a fact to be concerned about, not necessarily an immediate call to action.
The risk is still real when what we do about it is shrug and wait.