Did you change thoughts or start anew?

  • OBJECTION!@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    1 hour ago

    I was raised Catholic but rejected it immediately on reaching an age of being able to reason. Like, around 13 I was like:

    I believe my religion because it’s what I was taught and my religion tells me that Muslims go to hell but I’m sure there’s some Muslim kid just like me who believes what they do because it’s what they’re taught. It’s only by pure chance that I happened to be born into the “right” religion, but then, from the other kid’s perspective, they were also born into the right religion, so how do we know who’s right, if either of us are?

    So that led me to ground my thinking in science and rationality. But I did that to an unhealthy degree, repressing my emotions and being miserable. Eventually, I stumbled onto Zen Buddhism, and I found the philosophical framework of it to be quite coherent, and that, in conjunction with studying psychology and practicing therapeutic techniques, helped me overcome a lot of that.

    But eventually I found myself at odds with a couple of points, most notably “right speech.” The Buddhist ideal is that you should refrain from saying something even if it’s true, unless the person you’re talking to would be receptive to it. Especially in 2016 (when I was in this phase), that sounded completely insane. Like, at a certain point, you have a responsibility to speak out about what’s happening, regardless of whether you think people will listen, and you can’t know if you’re going to change someone’s mind until you try. For all the stuff I dislike about American culture, the norm of bluntly voicing your opinion is one of the few things I actually do like. Especially in the age of online discourse, that sort of “sitting back and waiting for the right moment” just means you’re ignored. Ultimately, I couldn’t resolve this disconnect and gave up on it altogether, though there were some perspectives from it that I still hold onto.

    Looking at politics, I found that the vast majority of people just don’t have their heads screwed on straight or their priorities in order at all. The whole reason I felt it necessary to come down off the metaphorical mountain and engage with worldly affairs was because of the rise of the domestic far-right, and the failure of liberalism and of the system to prevent it. That was and is my focus, and the center of my political priorities, finding a way to deal with these people who I watched become more and more unhinged and extreme, whether that be by force, or by addressing the root causes of their radicalization, or whatever else. I did not come down off the mountain to deal with every problem everywhere in the world, to do everything exactly perfectly, nor did I come down off the mountain because I felt it was crucially important to deal with China or Russia or Iran or anybody else. It’s the domestic fascists, who pose an actual, pressing threat to my safety, and to the safety of the world.

    The only people I found who consistently shared that priority were Marxist-Leninists. I only had a vague idea of what they believed, but they were the only people who were remotely aligned with my own politics, so I “caucused” with them, for lack of a better word. Everyone else is just weird tbh. Like, people get obsessed with trivial bullshit like the ballroom, or they get distracted by things happening on the other side of the world where it’s like, the fuck am I supposed to do about that anyway? You’ve got people throwing around the word “fascist” at anybody who isn’t precisely aligned with all of their foreign policy views, like wtf? How is any of that your priority while masked men are raiding workplaces and dragging our friends and neighbors away to secret torture dungeons? It’s just bizarre.

    Eventually, I read up on theory and got to the point where I didn’t see much reason not to apply the label to myself. But it was never because of Marx or Lenin or anybody that I got where I am, and tbh I kinda see myself as doing my own thing first and foremost, using their political analysis to whatever extent I might find it useful or compelling. It’s just that my own thing doesn’t seem to contradict their thing significantly.

  • yewg85lcx@feddit.uk
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    3 hours ago

    Born in catholic community.

    Now, moving towards Stoicism.

    I like that it’s a practical philosophy that anyone can explore, regardless of their education or background.

    One of its central ideas is that, even when we can’t control what happens around us, we can take responsibility for how we respond. Practices like negative visualization and cognitive reframing can help us prepare for life’s challenges and meet them with a clearer mind.

    Does anyone here practice Stoicism? Which is the idea/ exercise have you found helpful?

  • normalentrance@lemmy.zip
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    3 hours ago

    Religion stopped making sense when I was around eight. I loved the social aspect, but the Bible/religion bit didn’t jive with my world view. I’m not a big magic and miracles kind of guy I guess. Some of the stories about being good and some of the morals hold up though.

    I just try to be a good person. I’m probably closest to a humanist atheist.

  • keithan@lemmy.zip
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    4 hours ago

    I changed and became an Agnostic. I live in a country of mostly Catholics and it’s fine but the reality is that most people let religion dictate their decisions. My country has laws that are made based on religious beliefs rather than what’s best for everyone (even with the "separation of church and state). Not to mention the religion was largely coerced onto my country since it was a part of the many projects the colonizers had in mind.

    I do not hate God nor do I blame Him, it is the people that changed my mind about the entire religion. I’ve actually even experienced being discriminated by a so called preacher for not believing in Him which was crazy lol

  • SpacemanSpiff@lemmy.zip
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    edit-2
    5 hours ago

    I’m a Quranist Muslim, or Quran-only Muslim.

    I reject the books of traditions and think most of them were manipulated during the Umayyad and Abbasid eras and copied from Christianity and Judaism. I think there is ample evidence for the alteration of the religion following the death of Muhammad and think it’s a very different, more open and progressive religion when you reject the books of traditions. When you take the Quran alone you realize that the only important metric is belief in God and doing good deeds. Everything else is extraneous. The Quran repeatedly states that everyone is rewarded and can get to heaven, no matter what their religion is, as long as they do good deeds. But the mainstream traditionalists reject that on a very flimsy basis. The only thing that matters is good deeds, and one of the most commonly repeated phrases in the Quran is “those who believe and do good deeds”. The book exhorts us repeatedly to do good deeds and to ignore unbelievers, but this is the opposite of how traditional Islam has developed

  • plud_klem@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    10 hours ago

    President of my church’s youth group in the deep south of the US. Even went to a Promise Keepers meeting once in the Cowboy’s stadium. Thanks to maybe equal parts Philosophy 101 in college, LSD, and never having my prayers answered, I have been a proud atheist for decades. Never looked back.

      • T0RB1T@piefed.ca
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        3
        ·
        edit-2
        13 hours ago

        That’s because it’s from a great book from a great author that I haven’t read Discworld! I’ve only read excerpts, but his style is so recognizable.

        When I looked it up, I saw the quote

        In the beginning there was nothing, which exploded.

        Attributed to him, and I guess just… didn’t read the whole thing? So I assumed “yep, my memory is right, now I get to post confidently!”

        Gosh do I ever love being proven wrong after “double checking” my work.

        Terry Pratchett’s writing is still brilliant and hilarious, but that’s not directly relevant here.

        I should still get around to actually reading Discworld…

        Even if that’s not relevant to this.

  • flandish@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    9 hours ago

    i lost a wife to breast cancer in 2011. i am catholic. but frankly only because lately i hope it’s true so i can see her again. my recent studies in philosophy have me interested in faiths again and also leftist stuff. mutual aid, etc. but i always settle on “i hope it’s true so i can see ppl i miss.” it helps me sleep i guess. i havent been to church since she passed. also a month after her death a guy jumped from our church’s roof. i responded as a firefighter. i never really recovered from the anger from that bloated dead guy who landed on the garden that was there when i escorted the coffin a few weeks prior. anyway. sorry for the ramble.

  • humanspiral@lemmy.ca
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    7 hours ago

    God is a humanist as religion. Humanism as philosophy. First rule of humanism is the right to selfish individual freedom so long as it doesn’t harm others. 2nd rule of humanism is that “policies for good”/humanist social prosperity must respect first rule.

  • GalacticGrapefruit@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    15
    ·
    edit-2
    17 hours ago

    Atheist humanist, with a little sprinkle of absurdism.

    I was raised in a cult (Mormonism), and easily the most crushing realization of my entire life was finding out that my entire identity as a human being–going back four generations–was based on a lie. Everything I saw about myself and the world was wrapped up in Mormon dogma.

    It took a long time for me to find myself again. I had to relearn right and wrong, good and evil, and what makes life worth living. There were a couple suicide attempts in that little trip, and I’m glad I didn’t actually do it.

    Human beings deserve to live. We deserve lives of dignity, meaning, and purpose–hard to do in a universe that inherently has no meaning, with short lives whose courses are dictated by arbitrary circumstances beyond our control. But all the same, if now is all we have, then now must be the most important time. There is no god, no magic, no great design that gives us a roadmap for this. So, what is the point?

    The little boy tossing dying starfish back in the ocean has an answer for that. “It makes a difference to that one.” I try to live by that.